Amir calls Hassan a "coward" and begs Hassan: "Hit me back!" But Hassan wont. He yells at Hassan to hit him back, but Hassan refuses. He pelts Hassan with the pomegranates, for instance, because he wants Hassan to hit him back. Amir and Hassan are the best of friends, although they are from different backgrounds. Hassan wrongs himself by hitting his own head with a pomegranate, which shows that even though Amir has clearly betrayed him, he has no intention of wronging him back. He crushes a pomegranate against his own forehead, asks Amir if he is satisfied, and leaves. Page 4 of 4 Discussion Questions 1. Why didnt anyone tell the truth about the rape? Hassan says nothing, and Amir starts pelting him with pomegranates. This is Amir's way of trying to 'get what he deserves'. he wants Hassan to fight back. It also proves Amir and Hassan spend most of their time outside. The two boys believe their friendship will last forever and they promise to always be there for each other. The Pomegranate Tree In The Kite Runner 866 Words | 4 Pages. "Amir suddenly picks up a pomegranate and asks Hassan what he would do if he threw it at him. Hassan says nothing, and Amir starts pelting him with pomegranates. He yells at Hassan to hit him back, but Hassan wont. Finally Hassan crushes a pomegranate against his own forehead and asks if Amir is satisfied. They played, watched the dubbed movies, read story books,flew kites together. When Amir hits Hassan with the pomegranates and demands that he fight back, Hassan smashes a pomegranate against his own forehead, sacrificing himself again for Amir, but it signifies the end of their friendship as Amir cannot stand the way Hassan sacrifices himself for him and it builds the guilt in Amir. I spat. Amir throws pomegranates at Hassan so that Hassan must fight him back. Amir even throws pomegranates at Hassan while yelling at him, trying to make Hassan angry enough to throw pomegranates at him in return. He pelts Hassan with the pomegranates, for instance, because he wants Hassan to hit him back. Hit me back!. After the rape scene, when Amir and Hassan visit their tree, things just aren't the same. why does Amir pelt Hassan with pomegranates. 8) Why does Amir want Hassan to hit him Amir wants Hassan to hit him with pomegranates to punish himself for not intervening and helping Hassan in the alley. Since he isnt telling Hassan why he wants him to do this he has no way of knowing that he saw him get raped and ran the other direction. Hassan was always there for Amir but one moment that I believe shows when Amir accepts his cowardice is at the pomegranate tree. Hit me back goddamn you!. Hassan refuses to hit Amir, but instead crushes a pomegranate against his Amir wants Hassan to hit him with pomegranates to punish himself for not intervening and helping Hassan in the alley. (8.88). This gives the impression that Amir, by himself, is not capable of standing up for himself even if he tries to. Furthermore, he called Hassan a coward and begged him to hit Amir back. He thinks to himself, I actually aspired to cowardice, because the alternative, the real reason I was running, was that Assef was right: nothing was free in the world. Hassan refused to hit his friend,and instead hit himself. Amir needs Hassan to hit him back because he wants them to be friends and equals, but by continuingly sacrificing himself for Amir and not standing up to him, Hassan proves he is his servant first and friend second. The Pomegranate Tree In The Kite Runner 866 Words | 4 Pages. Amir and Hassan spend most of their time outside. Hit me back, goddamn you! I wish he would. Amir is frustrated that Hassan won't fight back and, in a larger sense, that Hassan won't hold Amir accountable for the rape. Amir and Hassan were childhood friends. As Hassan refused to fight back, Amir threw countless pomegranates at him until he was stained in blood-red juice. Amir struggles to do something, to stop Assef but instead, he ran. The pomegranates themselves represent the pain that Hassan will endure for Amir, and the juice from the pomegranates represents the blood that he will shed. He crushes a pomegranate against his own forehead, asks Amir if he is satisfied, and leaves. Shocked by the attack, Hassan does not understand how Amir feels, he simply does not want to hurt Amir. Amir is afraid to be Hassans true friend because of their different status and he is jealous of Hassan because he sees how much Baba cares for him. The Kite Runner Essay Questions. Under the guise of reading a new story that he had written, Amir invites Hassan to the tree. What Amir does, though, is hurl a pomegranate at Hassan. Amir longs for Hassan to hit him back; Amir desires some sort of physical punishment. But Hassan is unwilling perhaps unable to strike back. A sweeping story of family, love, and friendship told against the devastating backdrop of the history of Afghanistan over the last thirty years, The Kite Runner is an unusual and powerful novel that has become a beloved, one-of-a-kind classic (Hosseini, Khaled). An old woman, a famous psychic, told me to plant a pomegranate tree in an orchard of pomegranates. Another event that helps show this is that they both aim for the left eye. Amir asks Hassan what he would do if he threw a pomegranate at him. Amir wants Hassan to hit him with pomegranates to punish himself for not intervening and helping Hassan in the alley. When Amir throws the pomegranates at Hassan and Hassan does not fight back. He then challenges, "'Hit me back!' Amir feels incredible guilt over sacrificing Hassan in order to get the blue kite, the kite he believed would cause his father to finally love him. But Hassan is unwilling perhaps unable to strike back. He thinks about Hassan and the pomegranates because when Amir was throwing the pomagranates at him and telling Hassan to fight back Hassan instead hit himself in the head with one. Amir suddenly picks up a pomegranate and asks Hassan what he would do if he threw it at him. In fact, after Amir pelts Hassan innumerable times, Hassan splits a fruit open and breaks it over his own head and then walks home. He yells at Hassan to hit him back, but Hassan refuses. The Kite Runner Key Questions: Key Maybe Hassan was the price I had Amir feels incredible guilt over sacrificing Hassan in order to get the blue kite, the kite he believed would cause his father to finally love him. On the pomegranate tree, it is inscribed Amir and Hassan, Kings of Kabul. It is significant that Amir tries to pick a fight with Hassan in front of that tree, because it is where they hung out the most throughout their childhood and have become closer and closer within time, which makes it symbolic as well. Amir begins pelting Hassan with pomegranates and yells at Hassan to hit him back. Babas political views cause tension. I wished hed give he punishment I craved, so maybe Id finally sleep at night 4. As Amir is reading Hassans letter, crates of pomegranates fall and splatter on the ground and are picked back up. 8) Why does Amir want Hassan to hit him Amir wants Hassan to hit him with pomegranates to punish himself for not intervening and helping Hassan in the alley. That summer of 1976, Amir turns thirteen is forced to have a birthday party, by Baba. Then seconds later Amir begins pelting Hassan with pomegranates while yelling at Hassan telling him to hit him back. Maybe then things c [an]ould return to how they show more content Amir started throwing pomegranates at him telling him to hit him back.. Hassan refused as Amir kept throwing them at him. Amir wants Hassan to hit him with pomegranates to punish himself for not intervening and helping Hassan in the alley. Hassan was willing to do anything for Amir but Amir was not and this is the solely reason why their friendship broke into pieces. Finally, Hassan took one final pomegranate and crushed it on his own head. Discuss Amirs trip to Jalalabad with his father, contrasting his expectations with the reality. I fell on my bed, buried my head under the pillow, and cried. Hassan refuses to answer and so Amir throws the pomegranate as hard as he can into Hassans chest. Why did Hassan still love Amir? Why does Amir want Hassan to hit him, and why do you think Hassan refuses? As the Russians advance into Afghanistan, why could people no longer be trusted? The story begins in Afghanistan in the 1960's, and follows Amir, a Pashtun and a member of the Kabul upper class. At least things would be out in the open then. 3. must pay attention to what angle the story is told from as the time period and place change and comes full circle at the end. He tortures Hassan by pelting him with pomegranates, expecting him to fight back. Amir continually hits Hassan with the pomegranates and as Hassan falls down Amir yells at Hassan by saying Get up, hit me (Hosseini, pg 86) Amir wants Hassan to hit him with a pomegranate so he can grieve his physical pain and as a punishment for his guilt towards Hassan. But Hassan wont. It soon becomes obvious that Amir wants Hassan to hit him back. Amir also comes to see Sohrab as a substitute for the child he and Soraya cannot have, and as a self-sacrificing father figure to Sohrab, Amir assumes the roles of Baba and Hassan. Hence, Amir is driven by his feelings of guilt. The journey to redemption are telling Hassan to hit him with the pomegranate, the actions after the pomegranates, and going to Kabul. This showed the pain that Hassan felt when he was got raped. The pomegranate tree was a place for Amir and Hassan to run away to and really get to know each other. (page 27)). helped Assef rape Hassan, was later raped himself, died in the fuel truck in route to Pakistan. Hassan is a Hazara with meant that his kind was treated as a fugitive especially when the taliban gained control. Why did Hassan and Ali leave? By doing so, he hoped to remove his burden of guilt. It is then later used by Sohrab to hit Assef making him blind in one eye. Now, Assef has done the punishing to Amir that he feels he has deserved. Amir wants Hassan to be able to defend from any Pashtun, as he didn't do it with Assef. He pelts Hassan with the pomegranates , for instance, because he wants Hassan to hit him back. Kite Runner Discussion Questions - Google Docs. After witnessing the rape of his best friend and servant, Hassan When Hassan finally convinces Amir to read to him in the pomegranate tree, Amir begins throwing pomegranates at Hassan in an attempt to provoke Hassan into hitting him. The two boys go up to the pomegranate tree and Amir begins to pelt Hassan with pomegranates. (Hosseini 92). 8) Why does Amir want Hassan to hit him Amir wants Hassan to hit him with pomegranates to punish himself for not intervening and helping Hassan in the alley. All Amir wanted was for Hassan to betray his loyalty to Amir and throw a pomagranate at him. Then Hassan leaves, covered in red juice, and Amir starts to cry". In one attempt to play with him, Amir expresses his anger and throws pomegranates at Hassan. When Amir hits Hassan with the pomegranates and demands that he fight back, Hassan smashes a pomegranate against his own forehead, sacrificing himself again for Amir, but it signifies the end of their friendship as Amir cannot stand the way Hassan sacrifices himself for him and it builds the guilt in Amir. Amirs journey to redemption started when he was only twelve years old. Why does Amir recall the sheeps slaughter during Hassans assault? Hassan refuses to hit Amir, but instead crushes a pomegranate against his Hassan redeems himself spiritually because when Hassan and Amir were younger he tries to do the same thing as Sohrab, but didnt actually hit Assef. Amir wants Hassan to hit him so that he learns how to defend himself against other Pashtuns, like he didn't do against Assef. At first, Amir tells himself he doesnt help Hassan because hes afraid of being hurt by Assef if he intervenes: I ran because I was a coward. Why does Amir want Hassan to throw pomegranates at him? He yells at Hassan to hit him back, but Hassan wont. When Hassan doesn't take the bait, but instead, allows himself to be hit by pomegranates, Amir feels even worse. At first, Amir tells himself he doesnt help Hassan because hes afraid of being hurt by Assef if he intervenes: I ran because I was a coward. Amir is not himself anymore and is frustrated. Punishment, he is ultimately fighting the darkest part of himself that betrayed Hassan. Amir starts hurling pomegranates at Hassan and yells, Hit me back!. The Tragedy of Hassan in the Kite Runner. Hassan resisted, he never fought back. He pelts Hassan with the pomegranates, for instance, because he wants Hassan to hit him back. 8) Why does Amir want Hassan to hit him Amir wants Hassan to hit him with pomegranates to punish himself for not intervening and helping Hassan in the alley. In essence, Amir attempts to provoke Hassan to act disloyal by standing up to Amir. They collect pomegranates and make small talk. When Amir and Hassan had gone to the hill,shortly after this incident, Amir hit Hassan with some pomegranates and told him to hit him back. Baba still responds with violence when angry and there is a nasty incident with the elderly Vietnamese couple in the grocery store. Im staying out of it (89). This makes Amir feel even worse, as it proves that Amir himself is weak and cowardly as compared with Hassan. The Kite Runner - Discussion Questions. 6. With the start of school, Amir spends hours alone in his room. Amir asks Hassan what he would do if he threw a pomegranate at him. Amir also throwing pomegranates at Hassan and Hassan not reacting shows how much guilt Amir has because he wants Hassan to hit him. That said, Hassan also infuriates Amir with his goodness. He does not want to forget anymore, meaning that after what had happened to Hassan the winter Amir won the kite tournament all hes ever wanted to do since then was to forget. Finally Hassan crushes a pomegranate against his own forehead and asks if Amir is satisfied. Then Hassan leaves, covered in red juice, and Amir starts to cry". This makes Amir feel even worse, as it proves that Amir himself is weak and cowardly as compared with Hassan. Later, he and Hassan walk up to the old pomegranate tree. However, there are few scholars focusing on the character of Hassan. The Kite Runner is a novel written in 2003 by Khaled Hosseini.It is his first novel, the second being A Thousand Splendid Suns and his third being And the Mountains Echoed.. The pomegranate has a deep red colour, reminiscent of blood. Hassan had selfless love for Amir, although he felt terribly sad by the turn of events, I don't think he harbored any ill will towards his brother. The role of Hassan in the story is significant. When the two are face-to-face, Amir wishes Hassan would punish him. Amirs journey to redemption started when he was only twelve years old. Amir takes this way as a way of him getting the worth punishment for what hes done. He yells at Hassan to hit him back, but Hassan wont. Hassan but if someone else that was more powerful than he was, like Assef told him too, then he might eat the dirt. Find Amir Beg online. 8) Why does Amir want Hassan to hit him Amir wants Hassan to hit him with pomegranates to punish himself for not intervening and helping Hassan in the alley. He knows that Hassan betrayed him, yet he still remains loyal to him (pg 98 Are you satisfied? In fact, after Amir pelts Hassan innumerable times, Hassan splits a fruit open and breaks it over his own head and then walks home. When Hassan said nothing, he threw the fruit at him and demanded that Hassan throw one back. Hassan thought good of the world and the people in it. Hassan is doing what a true friend would but Amir on the other hand was doing nothing to keep The second visit to the pomegranate tree occurs after Hassan gets raped and Amir wants Hassan to punish him, as this might make Amir feel better and return things to the way they were. But Hassan proves that his loyalty and love for Amir are unwavering, as he does not retaliate. Why does Amir want Hassan to hit him, and why do you think Hassan refuses? historical knowledge of Afghanistan is important. Hassan is excited to go, and they sit under their pomegranate tree. The pomegranate tree is a symbol of friendship, childhood innocence, and shelter. After witnessing the rape of his best friend and servant, Hassan Amir hurls the piece of fruit at Hassan's chest and begs Hassan to hit him back. After Amir watches Assef rape Hassan, he has trouble rekindling his relationship with Hassan. That;s like their happy spot and Amir just starts pelting Hassan with pomegranates, wanting Hassan to hit him back. At one point he asks Hassan to go up their favorite hill where he began hitting Hassan with pomegranates with the hope that he would hit himself. But, Amir took their relationship for granted. The reason for Amirs behavior is because it will give [him] the punishment [he craves], so maybe [he will] finally sleep at night. Date: 2021-1-6 | Size: 11.8Mb. Then Hassan Maybe Hassan was the price I had to pay, the lamb I had to slay, to win Baba. Amir wanted Hassan to throw them back, but Hassan was completely loyal to Amir. Amir and Hassan Win the Kite Flying Competition After a long day of flying kites, Amir cuts the last kite string with the help of Hassan. The pomegranate tree was an important part of Amirs childhood because he spent a lot of his time sitting underneath it reading to Hassan. Do you feel better?). But Hassan wont. This is Amir's way of trying to 'get what he deserves'. Amir and Hassan are the best of friends, although they are from different backgrounds. But I had to do it at night, without telling anyone. 'Get up! Discuss the symbolism of the scene in which Amir throws pomegranates at Hassan. Amir then turns ands sees "Baba standing on the edge, pumpping both of his fists. Hence, Amir is driven by his feelings of guilt. Why does Amir want Hassan to hit him, and why do you think Hassan refuses? When the two are face-to-face, Amir wishes Hassan would punish him. Instagram, Twitter, Facebook, TikTok, Images and more on IDCrawl - the leading free people search engine. June 3, 2020 by Essay Writer. Sohrab technically finishes the job for Hassan by hitting Assef with his slingshot. Amir feels incredible guilt over sacrificing Hassan in order to get the blue kite, the kite he believed would cause his father to finally love him. When Amir hits Hassan with the pomegranates and demands that he fight back, Hassan smashes a pomegranate against his own forehead, sacrificing himself again for Amir, but it signifies the end of their friendship as Amir cannot stand the way Hassan sacrifices himself for him and it builds the guilt in Amir. Punishment, Amir feels, would at least begin to make up for the way he wronged Hassan. For instance, I remember the two boys staying at the pomegranate tree nearby the neighbourhood when Amir started to pelt Hassan with pomegranates. After they picked pomegranates, Amir asked Hassan what he would do if he threw a pomegranate at him. Why did Hassan lie about the watch and money? Why does Amir want Hassan to throw pomegranates at him? One summer day I used one of Ali's kitchen knives to carve our names on it, 'Amir and Hassan the sultans of Kabul." In doing this, as Hassan once did for him, Amir redeems himself, which is why he feels relief even as Assef beats him. 28 thoughts on The Kite Runner-Discussion Question #2 . Why does Hassan hit himself with pomegranates? What Amir does, though, is hurl a pomegranate at Hassan. He had even gone looking for punishment in the past, as when he tried to get Hassan to hit him with the pomegranates, because he felt then there would at least be some justice for the way he treated Hassan. Hassan couldn't attack Amir, as he respects him, and, as he said before, he would even eat dirt for him. Then, suddenly, Amir pelts Hassan with a pomegranate, which explodes all over his clothes. Instead, he picked one up off the ground and hit himself with a pomegranate instead, and asked Amir, "Happy now?" When the two are face-to-face, Amir wishes Hassan would punish him . Acces PDF Kite Runner Questions And Answers Hassan in the alley? Amir wanted Hassan to lash out at him. he lashes out due to guilt. Amir begins pelting Hassan with pomegranates and yells at Hassan to hit him back. 1) Discuss the symbolism of the scene in which Amir throws pomegranates at Hassan. help Hassan in the 7) Why doesnt Amir help Page 10/31. However, Hassan does nothing of Khala Jamila Taheri. But he didnt do anything like that, and when I opened the door minutes later, he wasnt there. He crushes a pomegranate against his own forehead, asks Amir if he is satisfied, and leaves. After Amir betrays Hassan, Hassan continues to serve Amir tirelessly.
National Public Safety Telecommunications Week 2021, Ronaldo Golden Boot Total, Ecofeminism In Literature Examples, The Skinners' School Ofsted, When Is Absu Post Utme 2020 Starting, Army Officer Retirement, Ac Syndicate Collectibles Rewards, Heritage House Resort Photos,